Connect
To Top

Rising Stars: Meet Blake And Tabbi Yager of Miami / South Florida

Today we’d like to introduce you to Blake And Tabbi Yager.

Hi Blake and Tabbi, we’d love for you to start by introducing yourself.
As a child, Blake collected sports cards obsessively. You didn’t need to ask what Blake wanted for a birthday or Christmas gift -it was always the same answer – cards. Got an A on his test? Baseball Cards. Mom needed him to behave – basketball cards.

More than collecting, Blake saw from an early age that he could make money by selling his cards. At 7 years old he had his parents order custom carbon-copy invoice/receipt paper title “Yager Card Sales”. Had Blake applied the same diligence he dedicated to studying the monthly Beckett Pricing Guide, he would have been an straight A student. Instead he skirted by in school while focusing on buying and selling cards.

After a brief reprieve during college and going to work for the family business, Blake was reintroduced to the world of card collecting in 2016. The industry was still booming but the game had changed. Card sales were happening every day online, on sites like eBay and before WhatNot or Tik Tok, early adapters were selling segments of expensive hobby boxes, known as breaking, on Facebook Groups.

Blake was immediately drawn back in and began breaking as a side hustle while still working full time for the family business and quickly found success. Blake suggested to his wife, Tabbi, that he could quit his job and start doing this full time. Tabbi (the person writing this) thought it was cute that Blake had found a hobby but didn’t think it would be enough to support their family. To prove this, I began tracking the expenses: inventory, supplies, mailing fees, etc… and after a few months it quickly became evident that Blake absolutely should quit his job and dedicate more time to this business and in 2017 he did just that.

While the business was doing well Blake could not shake the idea of opening a brick and mortar retail store. Taking the business offline and working with the local community. In 2022 Blake and Tabbi took a leap of faith – selling their home and using the money to open Hobby Card Shop in Jupiter, Florida. Hanging out with seasoned hobbyists, helping introduce families and kids to the collecting hobby, and sharing their wealth of knowledge advising other people on how to enjoy the hobby and to make money doing so.

Today Hobby Card Shop is in its fourth year, open seven days a week, and employing 6 people. From Pokemon to Sports Cards, and Singles to Sealed Wax, Hobby Card Shop has something for everyone. It was designed to be the “Apple” of local card shops, while providing the customer service of a mom-an-pop small business.

I’m sure it wasn’t obstacle-free, but would you say the journey has been fairly smooth so far?
Like most small businesses our first year felt like failure was inevitable. Balancing paying bills and ordering inventory on threadbare profit margins while living off of credit cards. The second year eased up a little and by the third year it started to feel like we were on to something.

One of our biggest fears was hiring staff; trusting our employees to treat our customers the way that we do; trusting employees with access to money and inventory. It was a scary step. Blake and I hadn’t take more than 2 days off in a row since opening the store as we approached year number 3. We needed help. We hired our first employee in June of 2025, our second in November, and again in February of 2026. Adding staff has given us the flexibility to focus on growing the business instead of being bogged down in the day-to-day minutia of operating the business. It is hands down one of the best business decisions that we have made.

Can you tell our readers more about what you do and what you think sets you apart from others?
Our primary role is to provide advice and guidance to the people that walk through the door.

When we first opened the store it was with the thought that we would be watching grown adults ripping expensive packs of cards while we watched and cheered them on. And this is definitely a part of what we do, but it turns out that it’s not the best part.

What we didn’t expect were the families and children that come into the store. It is truly magical seeing the hobby in it’s purist form and that is what happens when kids come into the store. Eight year old’s just want a Shohei Ohtani card in their collection, it doesn’t matter if it’s a valuable card or not – they just want to open their binders and find all of their favorite players. They don’t care if the Charizard card is rare and valuable, they just like the artwork. There is a purity that we get to witness everyday and it truly rewarding. Someday these kids will be 40 years old and talking about walking in to their local card shop, and it will be us that they are talking about. You know that saying about not working a day in your life… it’s when you get to be in roles like this. We are so grateful to wake up and come into the shop.

It’s not all sunshine and roses here. We are working with items that have perceived value and how you value and item may be different than how I value an item. There are a variety of tools that are available that provide market values for cards and if we are using different tools, we are going to see different numbers. We may interpret trends differently. Negotiations can be tense but we always try to keep in mind that all parties are simply trying to do what’s best for themselves and it’s not personal. We always strive to have fair deals but sometimes things just don’t come together.

Another aspect of the industry is card grading. We provide advice to customers every day on what cards should and should not be graded. Grading cards involves mailing your cards into a third party who will provide an opinion on the condition of a card, giving it a grade of 1-10. Grading cards can increase the value of your cards allowing you to make a stronger profit when you sell a card. But grading guidelines and strict and cards that appear to be in good shape at first glance often do not hold up under closer scrutiny.

What matters most to you?
Making sure that our customers have a good experience when they come in will always matter the most. Our business is not seasonal, we do not see a significant bump from snow birds or even from Spring Training (despite being steps away from the Miami Marlins and St Louis Cardinals Spring Training Facilities). Our business has found success with our local, full time residents and they will always be the most important element of our business.

Contact Info:

Two children browse sports merchandise in a store, with display boxes and pennants on shelves.

Four people stand around a display case beneath colorful sports pennants and framed memorabilia.

People browse a shop counter displaying sports memorabilia and collectibles.

Two shop employees stand behind a counter while a customer in a white shirt faces them; shelves and a glass display case surround them.

Several people stand at a glass display counter in a shop, with shirts and products visible behind them.

People gather around a glass display case beneath a wall of sports team pennants.

Person in a red shirt arranging boxed merchandise on a store display shelf.

People browse sports memorabilia beneath a neon football player sign and hanging team pennants.

Several people stand around a glass display counter in a hobby shop filled with collectibles and model kits.

People browse a hobby shop with shelves of trading cards and collectibles, display cases, and colorful signs.

Suggest a Story: VoyageMIA is built on recommendations from the community; it’s how we uncover hidden gems, so if you or someone you know deserves recognition please let us know here.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More in Local Stories

  • Community Highlights:

    The community highlights series is one that our team is very excited about.  We’ve always wanted to foster certain habits within...

    Local StoriesSeptember 8, 2021
  • Heart to Heart with Whitley: Episode 4

    You are going to love our next episode where Whitley interviews the incredibly successful, articulate and inspiring Monica Stockhausen. If you...

    Whitley PorterSeptember 1, 2021
  • Introverted Entrepreneur Success Stories: Episode 3

    We are thrilled to present Introverted Entrepreneur Success Stories, a show we’ve launched with sales and marketing expert Aleasha Bahr. Aleasha...

    Local StoriesAugust 25, 2021